|
Another word from a podcast this week. Last time, we looked at a guest's bona fide credentials. In that same conversation, the host mentioned being skeptical and doing "due diligence" when researching someone's background. That skeptical?
You may already see the derivational suffix in this word, but could there be another suffix as well? A word's orthographic denotation can be seen in its relatives. We might also have a consonant cluster that provides a clue to our word's language of origin.
|
Meaning
What is this word's meaning and how does the word function?
When I think of the word skeptical, I think of a sideways glance and a mistrustful nature. I believe I'm a skepticin general; I don't believe much right off the bat, including scientific word study. When I first encountered this work, I was skeptical. After all, people can say anything on the Internet. After some time reading and learning and looking at the work of Carol Chomsky, Richard Venezky, DW Cummings, Edward Carney, Vivian Cook, and others, I began to warm up to the idea.
Then I was skeptical of its educational value for students. I was so deeply entrenched in sound being the gateway to spelling that I found it hard to believe that students would be successful with all of this information. Like many, I didn't think etymology was necessary. I certainly didn't believe this was appropriate for beginning learners.
It took much study and practice to convince me otherwise. Perhaps it won't take you as long.
When someone is a skeptic, they "habitually doubt, question, or suspend judgement" according to the entry in the Collins dictionary. But I found something else interesting in the entry.
Apparently, the British spelling uses sceptical. Hmmm...
Given that this newsletter has readers from all around the world, I'm curious which spelling you use. I tell my students that some words have variant spellings that may depend on where you are from. Either is acceptable.
|
Structure
What are the elements that make up this word's structure?
I am no longer a skeptic when it comes to scientific word study, but the fact a skeptic can be skeptical gave me my first clue into this word's structure:
skeptic + al
The suffix has many uses in English. Here it is creating an adjective from the noun skeptic. We see this same function in words like magical or musical. Elsewhere, it may take a verb and derive a noun, like survival. Again, one must be skeptical of the lists of definitions of affixes we find in some published resources.
But what about the basic (base/ + ic) and classic(class + ic).
skept + ic + al
If this is my final hypothesis, then I'm saying our base is
We can find more information by looking at the entry for skeptic in Etymonline.
A skeptic was a member of an ancient Greek school that doubted the possibility of real knowledge. We received this word first from French which of course inherited it from Latin, which in turn took it from Greek skeptikos. It is related to a Greek verb, skeptesthai, "to reflect, look, view." The word took on its current meaning of doubt in the 1600s.
More about that
|
Relatives
What are the word's relatives and history?
So what other words can we add to a matrix with a base of skepticism can join our matrix.
Sometimes it is more interesting to look at the etymological relatives. If we take our word all the way back to its Proto-Indo-European (PIE) origins, we watch how this word developed in other languages. If we stay in Greek, we see that it developed into another verb that gives us the base microscope or stethoscope. In Latin, we have the verb specere, which gives us prospect, spectacular and conspicuous. From the Germanic families, we get spy.
The orthographic denotation of each of these words has something to do with "watching." Although many words in this larger family, like spice, have drifted in meaning, their orthographic denotation lingers in some sense. Even spice can be traced back to species and "how a thing looks."
|
Graphemes
What can the pronunciation of the word teach us about the relationship of its graphemes and its phonology?
When I heard this word in the podcast, I wondered if the egg, get, and the pronouns they, them and their.
In addition, we have many doublets that have an
skirt/shirt scatter/shatter
We also have other words with
sky skin skull skill
Alas, this was not true for skeptical. However, this word told us a different story.
Although there was a kalends, which is where we obtained our modern word, calendar. Therefore, any word that Latin took from Greek, it replaced the languages adopt and adapt them into their orthography.
|
Next Steps
What concepts from this investigation can we explore next to learn more about the English orthographic system?
|
What are all the functions of a suffix <-al>? (Big Idea #4) |
|
|
|
Your student may enjoy exploring the words we get from Old Norse and how these words from the Vikings arrived in our language. (Big Idea #6) |
I still practice a little healthy skepticism, keeping a watchful eye on anything new that purports to solve all our problems in education (I see you AI!). However, with their interest and enthusiasm, my students have shown me why I no longer need to be skeptical of studying words scientifically.
Stay curious,
Brad
Sign up for the newsletter!
Join the community! PS. Come see why I'm not a skeptic anymore! And perhaps meet a colleague or two who can help you through. The Creating English Orthographers (CEO) community is a great place to meet others interested in investigating words scientifically. Join us at the link below my signature!
PPS. Ok, so this word wasn't Viking. Did you know neither were the people, so to speak? "To go viking," or vikingr was a verb meant "going out to sea," mostly for raiding and exploring. Viking was not an ethnicity nor a national identity; most were farmers and fishermen.
|
|
|
|